Why "Greyhound" with Tom Hanks is good - an emotional film about the war
Educational Program Cinema / / December 31, 2020
Aaron Schneider's war movie ("Bury Me Alive"), based on the script, was released on Apple TV + streaming service. Tom Hanks. Initially, the film was planned to be released in wide distribution, but due to quarantine, the premiere was moved online.
This is a really big loss for the creators in terms of entertainment. Tom Hanks, who has been developing the Greyhound for about 10 years, has already expressed Tom Hanks on surviving coronavirus: 'I had crippling body aches, fatigue and couldn't concentrate' regrets about the purely digital release. Although he later addedTom Hanks Clarifies Greyhound Apple TV + Commentsthat I'm glad to be able to show the film now.
In fact, even at home viewing "Greyhound" does not lose its charm, because the shooting and special effects are secondary here. First of all, it is a touching story about people and a story about the horrors of war.
The story of one voyage
During Second World War Captain Ernest Krause takes command of the US Navy destroyer Greyhound. On the first voyage, where he accompanies merchant ships, German submarines are trying to attack the convoy. The team has to confront the superior forces of the enemy.
Of course, Americans love to make movies about World War II. In particular, about the battles on sea. As recently as 2019, Roland Emmerich's film "Midway" was released, dedicated to the famous battle. But "Greyhound" allows you to look at events from a slightly different angle.
He does not aim at globality and heroism, for which domestic viewers criticize Western cinema (often quite deservedly). This film is not about a major victory or the turning points of a war. The Greyhound tells about only one voyage of one ship.
This approach allows you to make the story more realistic and human: several main characters, one storyline. But at the same time, incredible emotionality.
Large-scale scenes and intimate setting
Of course, the main characters will take part in the battle. But still, the emphasis is placed more directly on the crew of the ship. The enemy appears here only in the distance, or even on the radio, and the activities and experiences of the team come to the fore.
This approach seems more plausible. They really had to fight the submarines blindly, focusing only on the readings of the instruments. And the effectiveness of hitting bombs was understood only by stains on the water and floating debris. This applies even more to night battles: it is difficult to track down enemies in the dark, but it is easy to open fire on your own.
And yet, in some moments, the film really shows large-scale scenes. One can argue how well the special effects are worked out: 50 million dollars were invested in the picture - half the amount of the aforementioned "Midway". At the same time, the large screen is sometimes very lacking. For example, the moment where a destroyer sails close to a huge ship simply requires a good picture and cool sound.
Most of the action takes place exclusively on the ship, and it is in the interior. The crew faces many problems that are rarely discussed in action films.
For example, it is difficult for a koku to cook hot food due to rolling. During the pursuit of a submarine, the window janitor may simply freeze, and the captain will find it uncomfortable to look ahead. Instruments break, sailors catch cold and sneeze. Dozens of such small details create a lively environment and help to feel all the difficulties of a marine life.
An unprepared viewer can be tired only by the abundance of slang. But here the authors had to choose - to indulge in simplicity or to try to convey what was happening believable.
Constant problem of choice
The plot of the film allows you to look at the war from another unexpected point of view. Krause not only has to fight enemies. He still has to constantly make a choice.
Indeed, many, for example, forget that during a war it is necessary not only to sink the enemy's submarine, but also to obtain evidence of the destruction of the target. The captain must decide whether to comply with the formalities or try to keep up with other ships. And then the choice becomes even more difficult. Rescuing people from a sinking ship or protecting another ship from attack? Your team's safety or helping your teammates?
Perhaps moments like this best show the horror of the war. After all, even the most noble people have to give up something and sacrifice something.
Tom Hanks onscreen and offscreen
Still, the emotional component of Greyhound, and indeed the appeal of this film, rests primarily on the lead actor. Tom Hanks literally in any way is able to show interesting details that turn character into a living person. And here he also worked on the script. So the actor's talent is fully revealed.
Ernest Krause is a true professional with great flair. Perhaps he even seems too experienced for the first voyage. But at the same time, the tough captain, after defeating the enemy, may simply forget to take off his helmet and it is ridiculous to walk in it until he is reminded.
He loses his appetite due to excitement, often prays. And he also confuses the names of his subordinates: the team did not have time to get used to it enough.
Such small features are often lacking in the brave military in the cinema: small mistakes, doubts, excitement. And it is they who make you worry about the hero exactly as a person. After all, he understands that he did not just sink an enemy submarine. He just killed 50 people.
The rest of the characters are only a background. The film is quickly becoming a one-man theater. And it's good that Hanks is able to pull all the action on himself.
"Greyhound" is not the brightest picture in terms of action. There were even too many blockbusters about WWII. However, such simple plots, where the main villain is the war itself, are useful and necessary. They do not cause controversy over which country has invested more in the victory, but simply show that it was hard and scary for everyone.
Read also⚓🚢⚔
- 33 feature films for history buffs
- 15 best roles of the incredible Adrian Brody
- "To the Stars" with Brad Pitt: a heavy drama about loneliness or "Interstellar" vice versa
- 12 best historical TV series
- What's Wrong with War of the Currents with Benedict Cumberbatch