How to behave with the supervisors in the transport, if something went wrong
Tips Right / / December 19, 2019
A small crib which will not get lost in difficult situations in the subway, bus or other public transport.
Who has the right to require the submission of my ticket?
People with ID supervisor. If a person refuses to submit such a document, you can safely ignore it.
The procedure is governed by the City Comptroller legislation and the organization being audited, so that exactly say whether he has the right to perform certain actions, you must first examine its officers instructions. Next we will look at what rights the Controller under federal law regardless of what organization he works.
Can the Controller to deliver free-rider to the police?
Yes, it has. In accordance with Article 27.2 of the Administrative Code, The supervisor may be forced to take you to the police station for a protocol. But only under the condition that doing so is in place it is impossible (for example, you forget your passport).
What if the supervisor insulted me?
article 5.61 of the Administrative Code It says:
Insult [...] punishable by an administrative fine on citizens in the amount of one thousand to three thousand rubles; on officials - from ten thousand to thirty thousand rubles.
You can simply remind supervisors about this article, or to record his words on the phone.
Can the supervisor to prohibit to shoot himself?
Not. Article 152.1 of the Civil Code It prohibits the publication of the video without his consent, but not create them.
Can I search the Controller?
In accordance with Article 27.7 of the Administrative Code, The supervisor can inspect your belongings in search of tools of administrative violation. If you can not produce a ticket controllers, and he has reason to believe that you have used, for example, someone else's social card, he has the right to make inspections. In this case the supervisor should be one floor to the passenger and inspection process - at camera fixed or held at witnesses.
And to remove someone else's social card?
Alien Social Card - is the subject of an administrative offense. Controller has the right to withdraw it (Article 27.10 of the Administrative Code).
Controller to land a man without a ticket of transport. So it is possible?
At the level of federal legislation the only thing that has to do with a controller of free riders - it draw up a protocol on administrative offense or offer the passenger to pay the fine without him. However, in more detail in the law are not spelled out the rights and responsibilities of supervisors in this regard, which makes inspection organizations the freedom to establish their own rules. So, for example, the job description Comptroller-Auditor "RZD" says:
In case passenger, passing without a travel document (ticket) or an invalid travel document (ticket) pay the fare [...] to take measures (including by means of the transport police) to remove the passenger from train.
Most likely, if the Controller needs to leave the transport, he has the right to do so to contrive a dispute about it not worth it.
Can the supervisor to keep me in the truck for a protocol or pay a fine?
Let's say, for the time showdown with controllers you have arrived at the right stop. In this case, you are not giving up the minutes, you can get out of the vehicle. If the supervisor will keep you power it violates the law. Indeed, in the list of persons entitled to administrative detention (Article 27.3 of the Administrative Code), No controllers. But the police can detain you.
What if I do not agree with the penalty?
Controller has the right to assign a monetary penalty free rider without a protocol. But the article 28.6 of the Administrative Code It says:
If the person against whom the administrative proceedings, disputes the existence of events administrative offenses and (or) assigned him an administrative penalty shall be made on the administrative protocol offense.
This means that you can not agree with the assigned you a fine in this case, the supervisor must draw up a report. However, continue to demand money from you, he has the right not to. Describe in detail in the report the reasons for your disagreement and put on it the signature.
Controller asks how I got into the trucks. I have to answer?
Suppose you used someone else's social security cards and the supervisor tries to find out how you passed the turnstiles. These questions can be safely ignored, because no one is obliged to testify against himself (Article 51 of the Constitution).
Can fine the occupant if he is younger than 16 years?
Not. In accordance with Article 2.3 of the Administrative CodePersons under 16 years can not be brought to administrative responsibility.